Skip to content
Drink Genius
Log in Sign up
All spirits Bourbon Scotch Whiskey Tequila Mezcal Rum Gin Vodka Brandy Liqueur Ready to Drink Everything else Taste finder Brands

Filters

Current selection
Dark Rum Type

Widely sold at normal retail. Leaves out allocated bottles and members-only.

Under $30 $300 and up

Live prices from Total Wine, BevMo, and specialty shops we list. Bottles without a current listing are left out of a price filter.

ABV %
to
Age (years)
to

Age filters skip bottles with no age statement.

A thin score moves a lot with one more review.

Only bottles with a measured profile can match a note.

Clear

Catalog

Dark Rum

393 bottles 3.71 median score $31 median price 3,645 ratings

Styles of Dark Rum

Dark Rum 347 Navy Rum 46
Filter Easy to find / buy Showing 1–24 of 393 bottles 393 bottles
Privateer Navy Yard Rum #1
Privateer

Privateer Navy Yard Rum

Rum Dark Rum Massachusettes 57.7% ABV
Dark Rum · Massachusettes
94 critic score
No live price
Brugal Leyenda #3
Brugal

Brugal Leyenda

Rum Dark Rum Dominican Republic 40% ABV
Dark Rum · Dominican Republic
Top 9% of rum
4.27 4.3 out of 5 5151 ratings
No live price
Goslings Family Reserve Old Rum #4
Goslings

Goslings Family Reserve Old Rum

Rum Dark Rum Bermuda 40% ABV
Dark Rum · Bermuda
Top 10% of rum
4.11 4.1 out of 5 104104 ratings
$78.99 Total Wine
Papa's Pilar Sherry Finish Dark Rum #5
Papa's Pilar

Papa's Pilar Sherry Finish Dark Rum

Rum Dark Rum Multiple Countries 43% ABV
Dark Rum · Multiple Countries
Top 10% of rum
4.12 4.1 out of 5 5858 ratings
No live price
Planteray O.F.T.D. Overproof Rum #6
Planteray

Planteray O.F.T.D. Overproof Rum

Rum Dark Rum Multiple Countries 69% ABV
Dark Rum · Multiple Countries
Above average of rum
4.06 4.1 out of 5 200200 ratings
No live price
Ten To One Caribbean Dark Rum #10
Ten To One Caribbean

Ten To One Caribbean Dark Rum

Rum Dark Rum Multiple Countries 40% ABV
Dark Rum · Multiple Countries
83 critic score
$37.99 Total Wine
Tiki Lovers Dark Rum #15
Tiki Lovers

Tiki Lovers Dark Rum

Rum Dark Rum Multiple Countries 57% ABV
Dark Rum · Multiple Countries
89 critic score
No live price
Ord River Orverproof Rum #16

Ord River Orverproof Rum

Rum Dark Rum Western Australia 56.4% ABV
Dark Rum · Western Australia
89 critic score
No live price
Papa's Pilar Flagship Dark Rum #17
Papa's Pilar

Papa's Pilar Flagship Dark Rum

Rum Dark Rum Multiple Countries 43% ABV
Dark Rum · Multiple Countries
Above average of rum
4.02 4.0 out of 5 150150 ratings
No live price
Cubaney Centenario #19
Cubaney

Cubaney Centenario

Rum Dark Rum Dominican Republic 41% ABV
Dark Rum · Dominican Republic
9 ratings
No live price
Wood's Old Navy Rum #20
Wood's

Wood's Old Navy Rum

Rum Dark Rum Guyana 57% ABV
Dark Rum · Guyana
86 critic score
No live price
Gunroom Navy Rum #21
Gunroom

Gunroom Navy Rum

Rum Dark Rum Multiple Countries 65% ABV
Dark Rum · Multiple Countries
90 critic score
No live price
Havana Club 15 Años #22
Havana Club

Havana Club 15 Años

Rum Dark Rum Cuba 40% ABV
Dark Rum · Cuba
12 ratings
No live price
Kōloa Kaua'i Dark Rum #23
Kōloa

Kōloa Kaua'i Dark Rum

Rum Dark Rum Hawaii 40% ABV
Dark Rum · Hawaii
Above average of rum
4.04 4.0 out of 5 4444 ratings
No live price